Supernatural props
Supernatural props for sale on Ireland's largest auction and classifieds sites
Supernatural first blade prop - blade, - £29.99
Supernatural first blade • Prop replica reproduction • Piece perfect fans - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural first blade • Prop replica reproduction • Piece perfect fans - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural angel blade - supernatural, - £21.50
Full sized castiel • Angelblade prop just • Like show high - Free postage - New and Used
Full sized castiel • Angelblade prop just • Like show high - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural sam winchester - sam, - £16.68
Set including holder • Cards badge black • Material faux - Free postage - New and Used
Set including holder • Cards badge black • Material faux - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural demon killing - supernatural, - £37.09
Full replica demon • Killing blade ruby • Knife from show - Free postage - New and Used
Full replica demon • Killing blade ruby • Knife from show - Free postage - New and Used
Looking for more supernatural props?
Search eBay live — fresh results filtered for the best value, updated every hour.
Supernatural the first blade - the, - £23.99
Are happy present • This high quality • Replica first blade - Free postage - New and Used
Are happy present • This high quality • Replica first blade - Free postage - New and Used
📊
48 listings · from £6.51 · avg £26.91
Browse 48 supernatural props listings currently in our index. Prices range from £6.51 to £90.9, with an average of £26.91. Whether you are hunting for a bargain or looking for a top-spec model, the selection below covers all price points — new, used and refurbished. More about supernatural props →
Supernatural show inspired - tv, - £26.70
Angel blade • Sale custom printed • Supernatural show inspired - Free postage - New and Used
Angel blade • Sale custom printed • Supernatural show inspired - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural angel blade kit - supernatural, blade' - £21.49
Angel blades are • Weapons carried most • Long silver triple - Free postage - New and Used
Angel blades are • Weapons carried most • Long silver triple - Free postage - New and Used
Printed supernatural angel - printed, - £24.99
Add celestial touch • Your collection this • Handmade printed display - Free postage - New and Used
Add celestial touch • Your collection this • Handmade printed display - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural show inspired - tv, - £13.47
Sale custom printed • Supernatural show inspired • Collapsible angel blade - Free postage - New and Used
Sale custom printed • Supernatural show inspired • Collapsible angel blade - Free postage - New and Used
Printed angel arch - 3d, angel/arch - £12.93
Bring piece supernatural • World into your • Collection this3d printed - Free postage - New and Used
Bring piece supernatural • World into your • Collection this3d printed - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural sam winchester - supernatural, - £15.34
Set including holder • Cards badge black • You may choose - Free postage - New and Used
Set including holder • Cards badge black • You may choose - Free postage - New and Used
Castiel from supernatural - castiel, - £39.99
They are free • Standing via strut • Easel reverse side - Free postage - New and Used
They are free • Standing via strut • Easel reverse side - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural angel blade - supernatural, 'angel - £24.61
Angel blades are • Weapons carried most • Long silver triple - Free postage - New and Used
Angel blades are • Weapons carried most • Long silver triple - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural ruby blade - 'ruby's, blade' - £28.77
Perfect fans show • Looking add unique • Piece their collection - Free postage - New and Used
Perfect fans show • Looking add unique • Piece their collection - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural the first blade - supernatural, - £21.49
Perfect fans show • Looking add unique • Piece their collection - Free postage - New and Used
Perfect fans show • Looking add unique • Piece their collection - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural first blade - first, - £34.99
Printed full first • Blade models may • Not achieve perfection - Free postage - New and Used
Printed full first • Blade models may • Not achieve perfection - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural sam winchester - supernatural, - £14.40
Set including holder • Cards badge - Free postage - New and Used
Set including holder • Cards badge - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural castiel badge - supernatural, - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience average • Card - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience average • Card - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural ruby - supernatural, ruby’s - £27.73
Demon killing blade • Supernatural lore into • Your collection this3d - Free postage - New and Used
Demon killing blade • Supernatural lore into • Your collection this3d - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural dean winchester - dean, - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience portrait • 95mm average card - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience portrait • 95mm average card - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural dean winchester - supernatural, - £16.20
Set including holder • Cards badge black • Material faux - Free postage - New and Used
Set including holder • Cards badge black • Material faux - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural kaz2y5 us - supernatural, - £15.00
- Free postage - New and Used
- Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural winchester a - winchester, c.i.a - £16.08
Set including holder • Cards badge - Free postage - New and Used
Set including holder • Cards badge - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural colt revolver - supernatural, 3d - £72.00
This amazing printed • Prop replica colt • Revolver from supernatural - Free postage - New and Used
This amazing printed • Prop replica colt • Revolver from supernatural - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural demon killing - supernatural, - £28.77
Full replica demon • Killing blade ruby • Knife from show - Free postage - New and Used
Full replica demon • Killing blade ruby • Knife from show - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural cosplay card - cosplay, - £9.00
Cosplay card choose • Its quirky design • Ability open supernatural - Free postage - New and Used
Cosplay card choose • Its quirky design • Ability open supernatural - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural winchester - supernatural, - £26.99
Landscape 98mm apologies • Inconvenience bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Landscape 98mm apologies • Inconvenience bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural archangel blade - supernatural, - £23.57
Blade archangel personal • Has similar appearance • Characteristics normal angel - Free postage - New and Used
Blade archangel personal • Has similar appearance • Characteristics normal angel - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural ruby blade - supernatural, blade' - £28.77
Full replica kit • Demon killing blade • Ruby knife from - Free postage - New and Used
Full replica kit • Demon killing blade • Ruby knife from - Free postage - New and Used
Replica supernatural demon - replica, - £19.08
Replica supernatural demon • Blade display stand • Beautifully painted assembled - Free postage - New and Used
Replica supernatural demon • Blade display stand • Beautifully painted assembled - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural blade set 3d - supernatural, - £57.89
Will need sanding • Priming painting prints • Are not 100 - Free postage - New and Used
Will need sanding • Priming painting prints • Are not 100 - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural angel blade - angel, - £19.08
Vanquish demons this • Scale supernatural angel • Blade replica printed - Free postage - New and Used
Vanquish demons this • Scale supernatural angel • Blade replica printed - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural key 3d - supernatural, - £6.51
Printedprop replica key • From show supernatural • Looking add unique - Free postage - New and Used
Printedprop replica key • From show supernatural • Looking add unique - Free postage - New and Used
The first blade - the, - £23.57
Supernatural into your • Collection thisfan made • Printed replica first - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural into your • Collection thisfan made • Printed replica first - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural dean s - |, dean’s - £15.45
Screen accurate plate • Exact replica - Free postage - New and Used
Screen accurate plate • Exact replica - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural demon hunter - supernatural, - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural the first blade - supernatural, - £60.00
Are happy present • This high quality • Replica first blade - Free postage - New and Used
Are happy present • This high quality • Replica first blade - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural crowley king - supernatural, - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Angel archangel demon blade - archangel, - £16.00
This generic sized • Display stand can • Fit any angel - Free postage - New and Used
This generic sized • Display stand can • Fit any angel - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural first blade - supernatural, – - £23.57
Supernatural into your • Collection thisfan made • Printed replica first - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural into your • Collection thisfan made • Printed replica first - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural sam winchester - supernatural, - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural lucifer playing - supernatural, - £54.49
Coa states that • Item was used • Titled production this - Free postage - New and Used
Coa states that • Item was used • Titled production this - Free postage - New and Used
Printed supernatural copper - printed, - £24.99
Add divine centerpiece • Your collection this • Handmade printed display - Free postage - New and Used
Add divine centerpiece • Your collection this • Handmade printed display - Free postage - New and Used
Sam winchester from - sam, - £39.99
They are free • Standing via strut • Easel reverse side - Free postage - New and Used
They are free • Standing via strut • Easel reverse side - Free postage - New and Used
Key supernatural 3d - key, - £10.79
Printedprop replica key • From show supernatural • Looking add unique - Free postage - New and Used
Printedprop replica key • From show supernatural • Looking add unique - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural colt revolver - colt, 3d - £85.00
Highly detailed supernatural • Colt revolver replica • Crafted from resin - Free postage - New and Used
Highly detailed supernatural • Colt revolver replica • Crafted from resin - Free postage - New and Used
Angel blade 3d - angel, - £26.69
Will need sanding • Priming painting prints • Are not 100 - Free postage - New and Used
Will need sanding • Priming painting prints • Are not 100 - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural first blade - supernatural, - £90.90
Supernatural first blade • Display stand screen • Accurate prop replica - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural first blade • Display stand screen • Accurate prop replica - Free postage - New and Used
Try this: swing gate motor | swivel rocker chair | table 6 chairs | table legs | table saw table | tall bar tables | tall headboards | tall oak bookcase | tall single wardrobe | tall skinny vases
Shop by budget
Everything you need to know about supernatural props
Whether you are looking for a brand-new or second-hand supernatural props, eBay offers one of the largest selections available online. With 48 active listings at the time of this page's last update, you have plenty of choice across different conditions, sellers and price points. The cheapest option currently starts at £6.51, while premium listings can reach £90.9 — giving you a wide budget spread to work with. The average price of £26.91 can serve as a useful benchmark: listings below this tend to be used or auction-style, while those above often include extra accessories, warranties, or are sold by professional sellers with high feedback scores. Always check the seller's feedback rating and return policy before committing to a purchase. If you need the item quickly, filter by "Buy It Now" to avoid the uncertainty of auctions. For used items, look closely at the condition description and photos — terms like "good", "very good" and "like new" can mean very different things depending on the seller.