Supernatural gifts
Supernatural gifts for sale on Ireland's largest auction and classifieds sites
New supernatural mug - supernatural, castiel - £6.25
11oz standard new • Item hand crafted • Home box care - Free postage - New and Used
11oz standard new • Item hand crafted • Home box care - Free postage - New and Used
Personalised supernatural dean - supernatural, - £7.59
Dean sam cass • Mug screationz unique • Characters from popular - Free postage - New and Used
Dean sam cass • Mug screationz unique • Characters from popular - Free postage - New and Used
Personalised family - personalised, - £10.99
Our glass worktop • Saver chopping board • Made from toughened - Free postage - New and Used
Our glass worktop • Saver chopping board • Made from toughened - Free postage - New and Used
Sam and dean - sam, mug - £10.79
Sam dean mug • Round ceramic coffee • Cup novelty design - Free postage - New and Used
Sam dean mug • Round ceramic coffee • Cup novelty design - Free postage - New and Used
Looking for more supernatural gifts?
Search eBay live — fresh results filtered for the best value, updated every hour.
New supernatural mug castiel - supernatural, - £6.25
11oz standard new • Item hand crafted • Home box care - Free postage - New and Used
11oz standard new • Item hand crafted • Home box care - Free postage - New and Used
📊
48 listings · from £1.7 · avg £10.72
⚠️ These listings were last updated more than 14 days ago.
Search for fresh listings
Browse 48 supernatural gifts listings currently in our index. Prices range from £1.7 to £36.6, with an average of £10.72. Whether you are hunting for a bargain or looking for a top-spec model, the selection below covers all price points — new, used and refurbished. More about supernatural gifts →
Greatest shows coffee mugs - shows, - £11.99
Greatest shows coffee • Mugs mug high • Quality 11oz - Free postage - New and Used
Greatest shows coffee • Mugs mug high • Quality 11oz - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural castiel badge - castiel, - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience average • Card - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience average • Card - Free postage - New and Used
Custom supernatural keychain - supernatural, - £16.15
Inspired supernatural engraved • Style design sam • Dean winchester fans - Free postage - New and Used
Inspired supernatural engraved • Style design sam • Dean winchester fans - Free postage - New and Used
Twilight dean sam winchester - twilight, - £3.00
Supernatural keyring one • Double sided acrylickey • Ring your choice - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural keyring one • Double sided acrylickey • Ring your choice - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural enamel pin - pin, badge - £5.99
- Free postage - New and Used
- Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural enamel pin badge - enamel, - £6.99
Need your order • Faster special occasion - Free postage - New and Used
Need your order • Faster special occasion - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural poster options - supernatural, - £4.99
This poster • Must have fans • Hit series supernatural - Free postage - New and Used
This poster • Must have fans • Hit series supernatural - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural necklace new gift - necklace, - £3.99
Supernatural necklace fine • Silver colour 50cm • Chain - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural necklace fine • Silver colour 50cm • Chain - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural flannel blanket - flannel, - £20.38
Fleece blanket will • Provide substantial warmth • Excellent experience you - Free postage - New and Used
Fleece blanket will • Provide substantial warmth • Excellent experience you - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural coffee mug - -, - £12.93
Coffee mug this • High quality 11oz • Microwave dishwasher safe - Free postage - New and Used
Coffee mug this • High quality 11oz • Microwave dishwasher safe - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural duvet cover - 3d, - £13.19
Duvet cover • 200cmx200cm pillowcases 50cmx75cm • 135cmx200cm - Free postage - New and Used
Duvet cover • 200cmx200cm pillowcases 50cmx75cm • 135cmx200cm - Free postage - New and Used
Dean sam castiel bobby - sam, - £7.96
Made 100 cotton • Making easy care • Suitable all seasons - Free postage - New and Used
Made 100 cotton • Making easy care • Suitable all seasons - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatual cast supernatural - supernatual, - £12.99
Use 1.4 micron • Thick gallery quality • Mount board all - Free postage - New and Used
Use 1.4 micron • Thick gallery quality • Mount board all - Free postage - New and Used
The gift vintage - the, horror - £10.80
Corgi 1982 first • Edition unearthed from • Vaults - Free postage - New and Used
Corgi 1982 first • Edition unearthed from • Vaults - Free postage - New and Used
Anime cartoon cosplay - anime, - £1.70
Brand new packaging • Nice box - Free postage - New and Used
Brand new packaging • Nice box - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural keychain - supernatural, - £5.98
Are made from • Supernatural inspired keychains • Suitable adults teens - Free postage - New and Used
Are made from • Supernatural inspired keychains • Suitable adults teens - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural season cast - season, - £14.99
- Free postage - New and Used
- Free postage - New and Used
New team dean mug supernatural - dean, - £6.25
11oz standard new • Item hand crafted • Home box care - Free postage - New and Used
11oz standard new • Item hand crafted • Home box care - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural show gift - supernatural, - £13.99
Stainless steel hand • Wash only - Free postage - New and Used
Stainless steel hand • Wash only - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural dean winchester - dean, - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience portrait • 95mm average card - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience portrait • 95mm average card - Free postage - New and Used
Know your signs - know, - £7.96
Made 100 cotton • Making easy care • Suitable all seasons - Free postage - New and Used
Made 100 cotton • Making easy care • Suitable all seasons - Free postage - New and Used
Jared padalecki fridge magnets - jared, - £5.44
Jared padeleckifridge magnets • High quality wood • Shiny finish magnet - Free postage - New and Used
Jared padeleckifridge magnets • High quality wood • Shiny finish magnet - Free postage - New and Used
Fridge magnets shows gift - magnets, - £5.09
Greatest shows fridge • Magnets high quality • Shiny finish magnet - Free postage - New and Used
Greatest shows fridge • Magnets high quality • Shiny finish magnet - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural blanket soft - supernatural, - £20.38
Fleece blanket will • Provide substantial warmth • Excellent experience you - Free postage - New and Used
Fleece blanket will • Provide substantial warmth • Excellent experience you - Free postage - New and Used
Hunter comic supernatural - hunter, best - £5.98
Product details printed • 100 cotton shirt • High quality print - Free postage - New and Used
Product details printed • 100 cotton shirt • High quality print - Free postage - New and Used
Surrounded by idjits - i'm, - £14.99
Fabric is100 cotton • Washes very well • Though good practice - Free postage - New and Used
Fabric is100 cotton • Washes very well • Though good practice - Free postage - New and Used
That was scary tshirt - that, sizes - £14.00
Must have fans • Iconic one liners • Supernatural chaos inspired - Free postage - New and Used
Must have fans • Iconic one liners • Supernatural chaos inspired - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural enamel pin badge - pin, - £5.99
- Free postage - New and Used
- Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural crowley king - king, of - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural coffee mug - supernatural, - £12.93
Coffee mug this • High quality 11oz • Microwave dishwasher safe - Free postage - New and Used
Coffee mug this • High quality 11oz • Microwave dishwasher safe - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural sam winchester - winchester, id - £8.99
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Apologies inconvenience average • Card bubbles silvering • Etc - Free postage - New and Used
Hey ass butt supernatural - hey, - £7.99
Ceramic mug produced - Free postage - New and Used
Ceramic mug produced - Free postage - New and Used
Greatest shows keyrings - shows, - £5.49
Greatest shows key • Rings - Free postage - New and Used
Greatest shows key • Rings - Free postage - New and Used
Official supernatural - official, - £9.73
Official supernatural anti • Possession tea coffee • Cup mug brand - Free postage - New and Used
Official supernatural anti • Possession tea coffee • Cup mug brand - Free postage - New and Used
Greatest shows coasters - tv, - £4.39
Greatest shows coasters • Premium quality hard • Shiny finish - Free postage - New and Used
Greatest shows coasters • Premium quality hard • Shiny finish - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural enamel pin badge - supernatural, - £4.99
- Free postage - New and Used
- Free postage - New and Used
Devils trap supernatural sam - supernatural, - £7.99
Ceramic mug produced - Free postage - New and Used
Ceramic mug produced - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural now and then - then, 20 - £14.01
Supernatural now then • Insulated tumbler versatile • Stylish drinkware option - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural now then • Insulated tumbler versatile • Stylish drinkware option - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural excellent gift - excellent, - £29.99
Use 1.4 micron • Thick gallery quality • Mount board all - Free postage - New and Used
Use 1.4 micron • Thick gallery quality • Mount board all - Free postage - New and Used
Personalised supernatural mug - personalised, - £9.03
Personalised mug supernatural • Team free will • Inspired - Free postage - New and Used
Personalised mug supernatural • Team free will • Inspired - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural mug tv show - /, - £9.99
Start your morning • Classic ride sturdy • Glossy built handle - Free postage - New and Used
Start your morning • Classic ride sturdy • Glossy built handle - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural drama bedding - tv, - £36.60
Duvet cover • Pillowcase function decorate • 135cm 200cm - Free postage - New and Used
Duvet cover • Pillowcase function decorate • 135cm 200cm - Free postage - New and Used
Supernatural bedding set - 3d, - £29.44
1pcs duvet cover • Pillowcase x30 50cmx75cm • 135cmx200cm pcs - Free postage - New and Used
1pcs duvet cover • Pillowcase x30 50cmx75cm • 135cmx200cm pcs - Free postage - New and Used
Try this: heaven can wait sweater | fat face green cardigan | clarks orinoco bloom | lipsy multiway dress | bardot dress debenhams | plt tracksuit set | balenciaga dust bag | debenhams push up bra | marks and spencer silver shoes | red herring lulu jeans
Shop by budget
Everything you need to know about supernatural gifts
Whether you are looking for a brand-new or second-hand supernatural gifts, eBay offers one of the largest selections available online. With 48 active listings at the time of this page's last update, you have plenty of choice across different conditions, sellers and price points. The cheapest option currently starts at £1.7, while premium listings can reach £36.6 — giving you a wide budget spread to work with. The average price of £10.72 can serve as a useful benchmark: listings below this tend to be used or auction-style, while those above often include extra accessories, warranties, or are sold by professional sellers with high feedback scores. Always check the seller's feedback rating and return policy before committing to a purchase. If you need the item quickly, filter by "Buy It Now" to avoid the uncertainty of auctions. For used items, look closely at the condition description and photos — terms like "good", "very good" and "like new" can mean very different things depending on the seller.